Second Shetland Truck System Report
-
Chapter 124 : 4563. Did you keep a lookout for that?-No; I have not gone to look yet.4564. Have you
4563. Did you keep a lookout for that?-No; I have not gone to look yet.
4564. Have you seen any of the men endeavouring to sell their fish to other people-to Messrs. Hay & Co. for instance, or to Mr.
Gavin Henderson?-I have seen them selling to Messrs. Hay & Co.
4565. Were these the small fish caught in the winter, or were they part of the catch of the boats that went to the summer fis.h.i.+ng and the haaf fis.h.i.+ng?-They were the small fish caught in the winter. I never saw any of the summer fish sold by any of Mr. Bruce's tenants to Messrs. Hay & Co.
4566. I suppose there is a greater inclination to sell the small fish caught in the winter for ready money than the summer fish?-Yes.
4567. Why are the men readier to do that?-Because, when they sell their fish to Messrs. Hay & Co., the merchant knows what he intends to give for them; and daily and nightly, when the fish have been delivered, they go to Hay & Co.'s store and get the value for them, and there is no more about it.
4568. They settle for them at once?-Yes,
4569. In money or in goods?-Generally in goods; but Messrs.
Hay's man will give them a s.h.i.+lling or so; whereas, if they had to go to Mr. Bruce's store with them, they would not know what they were to get until the settlement, neither would they get the goods at so low a figure.
4570. They get the goods cheaper at Hay & Co.'s?-Yes, a little.
4571. Is there any other article than meal the price of which you have compared with what it could be got for at other stores?-Not particularly, because I have not had much dealings at the store, as I generally dealt with other merchants.
4572. Is there anything else you wish to add to what you have said or to what the other men have said?-Nothing particular.
Lerwick, January 9, 1872, JOHN HARPER, examined.
4573. Are you a fisherman at Lingord, Dunrossness?-I am.
4574. Do you hold land there under Mr Bruce of Sumburgh?- Yes.
4575. Do you hold it subject to the condition of delivering your fish to Mr. Bruce in the same way that the other men have spoken to?-Yes.
4576. You have heard the evidence of William Goudie, Laurence Smith, and Henry Gilbertson?-Yes.
4577. Have they described correctly the way in which you deal at Mr. Bruce's shop for goods?-Quite correctly, so far as my experience goes.
4578. Do you deal in the same way?-Yes; but I deal very little there.
4579. Where do you get your goods?-I get them at different places, but my chief dealings are at Gavin Henderson's. I have also some dealings at Mr. Bruce's store at Boddam, kept by Henry Isbister, which is close beside where I live.
4580. Do you generally receive a large balance at the end of the year in cash?-Yes, I am always paid in cash.
4581. How much of a balance in cash did you get last year?-I cannot remember exactly; and I have no copy of my account.
4582. Was it 5 or 6, or more?-I think it was 5 or 6, and the rest of my earnings went to pay my land rent and shop accounts.
4583. Have you made any comparison as to the prices of goods at the Boddam shop and the prices at which you could get them elsewhere?-I have not made a strict comparison, but the Boddam shop and the other shops do not differ much in most things.
4584. Have you anything to add to what has been said by the other witnesses?-We would be very happy to have the liberty of curing our fish ourselves.
4585. Have you tried that?-Yes; I have tried it in former times before I was taken under Mr. Bruce.
4586. Where was that?-At the same place where I am fis.h.i.+ng yet.
4587. You had your liberty then?-Yes.
4588. Do you think that in those days you made a larger profit on your fish than you do now?-I did; but there would be a difficulty in doing that now, unless we had the power of using the beaches to dry our fish on. If we did not have that power, we could make nothing of it at all
4589. In those days the price of fish would be quite different from what it is now? It would be much lower when you used to cure your own fish?-In the former part of the time when I used to cure them it was lower than it is now, and indeed it was rather lower all through. I don't know exactly what those that cured their own fish this year have got for dried fish, but I think I got 10s. 6d. per cwt.
of dried saith of my own curing during the last year when I cured them.
4590. What is the price now for cured fish?-I have heard that it is 12s.
4591. I suppose there was not much difference in those days in the price of cured fish?-No; but it did differ according to seasons.
Every season was not exactly alike.
4592. Would that be twelve years ago?-Yes.
4593. In what way have you calculated that you would make more profit upon the fish of your own curing than is paid to you by Mr.
Bruce?-I have just made a calculation in my own mind according to the quant.i.ty of fish I caught then and what I catch now. It is merely a calculation of my own, and I do not say it is exactly correct.
4594. Did you make that calculation lately?-No; only I have always been of that opinion since I was obliged to deliver my fish to Mr. Bruce.
4595. Have you not made a note of the value of your green fish, the expense of materials for curing, and the value of the labour that you would require to put upon them, in order to ascertain whether you would get as much for your cured fish as you do for your green, or more?-I have paid some attention to that matter; but of course, in any case where a man dries his fish for himself, he must expect to have a little more work than he has when delivering them green. There would thus be extra expense for my own labour.
4596. There would also be the price for salt, and other things required, in the curing?-Yes; we would have to calculate all these things.
4597. Would you not be at a disadvantage from not having vats and other apparatus suitable for curing?-There would be rather a disadvantage in that way now, but there was not such a disadvantage formerly, because we had these things; and when we were stopped from curing for ourselves, we had to dispose of them as we had no use for them.
4598. Did each fisherman commonly possess these things?-Yes, at that time.
4599. Or was it each boat's crew who owned these implements?- Yes.
4600. Each boat's crew had a supply of apparatus for curing their fis.h.i.+ng?-Yes, for their own use. They generally had a vat and other instruments according to what they required.
4601. Do you think they were as skilful in the use of these instruments as the curers are now?-I don't think they were very much behind, because the curer who cures the fish we catch now was formerly a fisherman, as I am myself. Further than the experience of years may have taught him, he knew nothing better about it than I did, for I cured fish when I was a beach boy, and I was also the head in it all through, until I was stopped from curing.
4602. In forming that opinion with regard to the profit which you would have by curing your own fish, have you taken into account the risk of having your own fish spoiled in the curing?-Of course we must run that risk.
4603. Then you might gain something in one year, but in another you might lose to some extent in the [Page 114] curing?-That is quite possible; but still, in the experience I formerly had, the loss was nothing to speak of.
4604. For how many years did you cure your own fish?-For a good many, perhaps five years. There is one thing I should like to state which has not been mentioned already; but I don't exactly know how far it will fall within your inquiry. That is about the days' works which are required from us in addition to our land rent.
4605. What do you mean by days' works?-It is labour imposed upon the tenants by the landlord. They must work three days'
work in summer. We don't exactly work these days' works in summer where we live; but we are bound to carry a boat of peats to those who live near Sumburgh, which stands in place of our three days in summer. Then we have to work three days in harvest, and three days in vore ( 4606. Is not that really part of the rent which you pay for your land?-We don't suppose so, because our land is valued, and we have to pay for it in cash, or it is taken off our account. 4607. You mean that you have to pay your rent in cash, and to give the days' works besides?-Yes; and we have to pay a poultry fowl for each merk of land.
